No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Beyond Voluntary: The 1998 Automotive CO2 Agreement and the Limits of Corporate Influence on Environmental Regulation
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 15 August 2025
Abstract
The automotive lobby’s voluntary commitment to reducing CO2 emissions in 1998 was widely perceived as evidence of the influence of multinationals on European decision-making. Nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) denounced the lack of transparency. Interviewing negotiators or quoting published reports, scholars focused on the disappointing effects of this agreement. Pending the opening of the public archives, this study is based on primary industry archives, which shed light on the highly confidential negotiation phase. Exchanges within the industry and meetings with the European Commission reveal the limits of the automotive lobby’s power, which had to face internal divisions and seemed to suffer more than choose the agreement. It was the result of Directorate-General (DG) III’s maneuvering. The companies “voluntarily” accepted it as the lesser evil, as it was more advantageous than a directive. The idea of standards being co-constructed by public and private stakeholders needs to be qualified: the balance of power was unbalanced. With these soft regulations, it was above all the Commission that strengthened its position in the decision-making process, to the detriment of other stakeholders such as the European Parliament.
Information
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © 2025 The President and Fellows of Harvard College
References
1 Walter A. Friedman and Geoffrey Jones, “Business History: Time for Debate,” Business History Review 85, no. 1 (2011): 6.
2 Ann-Kristin Bergquist, “Renewing Business History in the Era of the Anthropocene,” Business History Review 93 (2019): 3–24, 7.
3 Masahiko Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence of Automobile Fuel Economy Regulations: A Comparative Analysis of EU, Japan and the US (Cham, 2015).
4 Paolo Bertoldi and Silvia Rezessy, “Voluntary Agreements for Energy Efficiency: Review and Results of European Experiences,” Energy & Environment 18, no. 1 (2007): 37–73.
5 Bergquist, “Renewing Business History,” 7.
6 Carlo Carraro and François Lévêque, eds., Voluntary Approaches in Environmental Policy (Dordrecht/Boston, MA, 1999); Andrea Baranzini and Philippe Thalmann, eds., Voluntary Approaches in Climate Policy (Cheltenham/Northampton, 2004).
7 Peter Bôrkey and Matthieu Glachant, “Les engagements volontaires de l’industrie : un mode original de réglementation environnementale,” Revue d’économie industrielle 83, no. 1 (1998): 213.
8 Axel Friedrich, Matthias Tappe, and Rüdiger Wurzel, “A New Approach to EU Environmental Policy-Making? The Auto-Oil I Programme,” Journal of European Public Policy 7, no. 4 (2000): 593–612.
9 Gernot Schnabl, “The Evolution of Voluntary Agreements at the Level of the European Union,” The Handbook of Environmental Voluntary Agreements: Design, Implementation and Evaluation Issues, ed. Edoardo Croci (Dordrecht/New York, 2005): 93.
10 Borkey and Glachant, “Les engagements volontaires,” 214.
11 Calculations based on data approved by European automotive CEOs in Dec. 1996, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA, Centre d’archives de Terre Blanche, Hérimoncourt, France.
12 Keetie Sluyterman, “Royal Dutch Shell: Company Strategies for Dealing with Environmental Issues,” Business History Review 84, no. 2 (2010): 203–226.
13 Andrew J. Hoffman, “Climate Change Strategy: The Business Logic Behind Voluntary Greenhouse Gas Reductions,” California Management Review 47, no. 3 (2004): 21–46.
14 Thomas P. Lyon and John W. Maxwell, “Self-Regulation, Taxation and Public Voluntary Environmental Agreements,” Journal of Public Economics 87, no. 7–8 (2003): 1453–1486; Frans P. De Vries, Andries Nentjes, and Neil Odam, “Voluntary Environmental Agreements: Lessons on Effectiveness, Efficiency and Spillover Potential,” International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics 6, no. 2 (2012): 119–152.
15 Volpi Giulio and Stephan Singer, “EU-Level Agreements: A Successful Tool? Lessons from the Agreement with the Automotive Industry,” in Voluntary Environmental Agreements: Process, Practice and Future Use, ed. Patrick ten Brink (Sheffield, 2002), 142–154.
16 Sarah Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis of the Voluntary Fuel Economy Agreement, Established by the European Automobile Manufacturers and the European Commission, with Regard to Its Capacity to Protect the Environment,” European Environmental Bureau (2000): 1–84.
17 David Coen and Jeremy Richardson, Lobbying the European Union: Institutions, Actors, and Issues (Oxford, 2009).
18 Julia Hildermeier, “Emission Legislation—Europeanization of the Automotive Sector,” How Ideas Change Markets: Social and Semantic Construction(s) of Automobility in 21st century Europe (Münster, 2016): 56–83.
19 Sigrun M. Wagner, “Environmental Policies and Lobbying by Automotive Makers in Europe,” in Sustaining Industrial Competitiveness after the Crisis: Lessons from the Automotive Industry, ed. Luciano Ciravegna (Basingstoke/New York, 2012): 201–225; Alexandra Quandt, “Voluntary Approaches in Climate Policy: Comparing European and Swiss Transport Legislation,” published by NCCR Climate (2010): 1–21; Sarah Keay-Bright, “A critical analysis.”
20 As most of these archives are in French, they have been translated in this article.
21 Sigfrido Ramírez Pérez, “Transnational Business Networks Propagating EC Industrial Policy: the Role of the Committee of Common Market Automobile Constructors,” The History of the European Union: Origins of a Trans- and Supranational Polity 1950–1972, eds. Wolfram Kaiser, Brigitte Leucht, and Morten Rasmussen (Abingdon, 2009): 74–92.
22 Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence.
23 Klebaner, Normes environnementales européennes et stratégies des constructeurs automobiles (Paris, 2020); Grace Ballor, “Liberal Environmentalism: The Public-Private Production of European Emissions Standards,” Business History Review 97, no. 3 (2023): 575–601; Alice Milor, “European Technical Democracy? How Consumer Associations Did—or Did Not—Shape the 1980s Automotive Environmental Standards,” Technology and Culture 65, no. 1 (2024): 265–291.
24 On road safety, see Marine Moguen-Toursel, “Emergence and Transfer of Vehicle Safety Standards: Why We Still Do Not Have Global Standards,” Entreprises et Histoire 51, no. 2 (2008): 88-102; Alice Milor, “Whose Business Is Road Safety? From a Fragmented to an Integrated Approach in France and Europe (1972–1998),” Transfers 9, no. 3 (2020): 41-60. On commercial issues, see Sigfrido Ramírez Pérez, “Embedding the Market during Times of Crisis: The European Automobile Cartel during a Decade of Crisis (1973–1985),” Business History 62, no. 5 (2020): 815-836; Grace Ballor, “Liberalisation or Protectionism for the Single Market? European Automakers and Japanese Competition, 1985–1999,” Business History 65, no. 2 (2023): 302–328.
25 Alice Milor, “Construire l’automobile, conduire l’Europe. Industriels, consommateurs et responsables politiques (1972–1998)” (Ph.D. diss, Sorbonne University, 2021).
26 Mattias Näsman, “The Political Economy of Emission Standards: Politics, Business and the making of Vehicle Emission Regulations in Sweden and Europe, 1960–1980s” (Ph.D. diss, Umeå University, 2021).
27 Samuel Klebaner and Sigfrido Ramírez Pérez, “Managing Technical Changes from the Scales of Legal Regulation: German Clean Cars against the European Pollutant Emissions Regulations in the 1980s,” Management & Organizational History 14, no. 4 (2019): 442-468.
28 Neil Rollings, “‘The Vast and Unsolved Enigma of Power’: Business History and Business Power,” Enterprise & Society 22, no. 4 (2021): 893–920.
29 Adrienne Héritier and Sandra Eckert, “New Modes of Governance in the Shadow of Hierarchy: Self-Regulation by Industry in Europe,” Journal of Public Policy 28, no. 1 (2008): 113–138.
30 Handelsblatt, 2–3 Mar. 1991.
31 Hildermeier, How Ideas Change Markets, 56–83; Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis,” 18.
32 Quandt, “Voluntary Approaches in Climate Policy,” 8.
33 Milor, “Construire l’automobile, conduire l’Europe,” 147–149.
34 Klebaner, Normes environnementales européennes.
35 European Commission (F. Andriessen and M. Bangemann), “A Large Internal Market for Automobiles,” 27 Apr. 1989; Alice Milor, “Non-documents for Big Decisions: The Commission and the EEC–Japan Automotive Agreement (1991),” Journal of Common Market Studies 62, no. 6 (2024): 1654–1671.
36 Héritier and Eckert, “New Modes of Governance.”
37 Dominique Pestre, “La mise en économie de l’environnement comme règle,” Écologie politique 52, no. 1 (2016): 38; Robert Falkner, Business Power and Conflict in International Environmental Politics (Basingstoke, 2008).
38 ACEA, “ACEA Voluntary Self-Commitment on Passenger Car Emission/CO2,” Oct. 1991, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
39 From Xavier Fels (Director of PSA’s External Relations Department) to CEO Jacques Calvet, Interview Guide for the Meeting with Corinne Lepage, 14 June 1996, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
40 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
41 ACEA minutes, CEO meeting in Geneva, Mar. 1995, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
42 ACEA, Meeting minutes, 1995.
43 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
44 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
45 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
46 Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence, 40–41.
47 Milor, “Construire l’automobile, conduire l’Europe,” 133–134, 139–141.
48 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
49 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
50 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
51 Fels to Calvet, 1996.
52 Note from PSA’s External Relations Department, 6 June 1997, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA. On Volvo, see Näsman, “The Political Economy of Emission Standards.”
53 “Memorandum of understanding between the Ministry of the Environment and Fiat,” Rome, 16 Apr. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
54 Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis,” 19.
55 Note from Jean-Claude Fontaine (PSA’s delegation in Brussels) to Xavier Fels, 5 Feb. 1999, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
56 Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence, 41.
57 Letter from Martin Bangemann (DG III) and Ritt Bjerregaard (DG XI) to ACEA’s President Jacques Calvet, 31 May 1996, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
58 Christian Casper (PSA’s delegation in Brussels), Interview Guide for the Meeting between Jacques Calvet (ACEA) and Martin Bangemann, 25 Oct. 1996, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
59 Hildermeier, How Ideas Change Markets, 61.
60 Casper, Interview Guide for Jacques Calvet, 1996.
61 ACEA minutes about the meeting between Jacques Calvet and Martin Bangemann on 31 Oct., 5 Nov. 1996, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
62 Note from PSA’s External Relations Department, 6 June 1997, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
63 Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence, 90.
64 Casper, Interview Guide for Jacques Calvet, 1996.
65 ACEA minutes, 5 Nov. 1996.
66 ACEA minutes, 5 Nov. 1996.
67 DG XI, “Orientation Paper on Commission Communication on CO2 emissions from transport,” Mar. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
68 Anonymized handwritten note from PSA, 1 Apr. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
69 Handwritten note from Xavier Fels (PSA) to Jean-Martin Folz (PSA), 1 Apr. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
70 Note from Jean-Marc Lepeu (Renault’s External Relations Department) to Louis Schweitzer (Renault CEO), Preparation for the ACEA CEO meeting on 4 Mar., 25 Feb. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
71 ACEA, “Presentation of the ACEA Technical Feasibility Study,” Workshop CO2 and Cars, Strasbourg, 18 Feb. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
72 ACEA, Presentation, Strasbourg, 1998.
73 Gijs Mom, The Electric Vehicle: Technology and Expectations in the Automobile Age (Baltimore, MD, 2004).
74 Kunibert Schmidt (VDA), “CO2 Reduction: Voluntary Agreement between ACEA and EU Commission,” 6 Oct. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
75 Public letter from Ritt Bjerregaard to Environment Ministers, 16 Oct. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
76 Public letter from Ritt Bjerregaard, 16 Oct. 1997.
77 Public letter from Ritt Bjerregaard, 16 Oct. 1997.
78 Schmidt, “CO2 Reduction,” 1997.
79 Note from Lepeu to Schweitzer (Renault), 1998.
80 Letter from Kunibert Schmidt (VDA) to Camille Blum (ACEA General Secretariat), 20 Nov. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
81 Schmidt to Blum, 1997.
82 Note from Xavier Fels to Jean-Martin Folz, handwritten comments on Schmidt’s letter to ACEA, 8 Dec. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
83 Schmidt to Blum, 1997.
84 Note from Xavier Fels to Jean-Martin Folz (PSA CEO), handwritten comments on Schmidt’s paper “CO2 Reduction,” 17 Oct. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
85 David Vogel, Fluctuating Fortunes: The Political Power of Business in America (Washington, DC, 1989); Robert Falkner, Business Power and Conflict in International Environmental Politics (Basingstoke, 2008).
86 Ramírez Pérez, “Transnational Business Networks”; Milor, “Construire l’automobile, conduire l’Europe”; Ballor, “Liberalisation or Protectionism.”
87 Fels’s comments on Schmidt’s paper, 1997. Ford representatives took part in Commission working groups on behalf of ACEA.
88 Fels’s comments on Schmidt’s paper, 1997.
89 Note from Julien Lamy (PSA’s delegation in Brussels) to Casper and Fels, 9 Dec. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
90 Note from Lamy, 9 Dec. 1997.
91 Sluyterman, “Royal Dutch Shell.”
92 Justin Greenwood, Inside the EU Business Associations (Basingstoke, 2002); Sylvain Laurens, Les courtiers du capitalisme: milieux d’affaires et bureaucrates à Bruxelles (Marseille, 2015).
93 Note from Lamy, 9 Dec. 1997.
94 Note from Lamy, 9 Dec. 1997.
95 David Vogel, “Trading up and Governing across: Transnational Governance and Environmental Protection,” Journal of European Public Policy 4, no. 4 (1997): 556–571; Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence; Gustavo Collantes and Daniel Sperling, “The Origin of California’s Zero Emission Vehicle Mandate,” Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 42, no. 10 (2008): 1302–1313.
96 Tom McCarthy, Auto Mania: Cars, Consumers, and the Environment (New Haven, CT, 2007); Rüdiger Wurzel, Environmental Policy-Making in Britain, Germany and the European Union (Manchester, 2002); Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence.
97 Note from Lamy to Casper and Fels, 18 Dec. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
98 James Palmer, “Geographies of Expertise in the Dieselgate Scandal: From a Politics of Accuracy to a Politics of Acceptability?” Area 54, no. 3 (2022) 482–489; Lee Vinsel, Moving Violations: Automobiles, Experts, and Regulations in the United States (Baltimore, MD, 2019); Näsman, “The Political Economy of Emission Standards.”
99 Note from Charles Caporale (PSA’s delegation in Brussels) to Casper and Fels, 11 Dec. 1997, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
100 Laurent Warlouzet, “The Role of the European Parliament in the Single Market Programme: The Cost of Non-Europe and the Car Emission Directive (1983–89),” Journal of European Integration History 27, no. 1 (2021): 21–36.
101 Letter from Georg Schaffner (Opel) to ACEA, 27 Feb. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
102 Luc Bastard (ACEA), ACEA’s note on CO2, 13 Jan. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
103 Urgent note from Camille Blum (ACEA) to ACEA’s members, 27 Feb. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
104 Urgent note from Camille Blum, 27 Feb. 1998.
105 Arthur D. Little, PowerPoint-type computer presentation, 28 Feb. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
106 Note from Lepeu to Schweitzer (Renault), 1998.
107 Schmidt, “CO2 Reduction,” 1997.
108 Note from Lepeu to Schweitzer (Renault), 1998.
109 Note from Lepeu to Schweitzer (Renault), 1998.
110 “Draft Interim Progress Report by Working Group for Cleaner Vehicles Task Force: For Discussion at Working Group Meeting on 29 April,” 20 Apr. 1998, NK69/21, UK National Archives.
111 “Draft Interim Progress Report,” 1998.
112 Handwritten note from Fels on a business card, Apr. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
113 Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis,” 14.
114 Note from Lepeu to Schweitzer (Renault), 1998.
115 Fels to Calvet, Interview Guide with Lepage, 1996.
116 Fels to Calvet, Interview Guide with Lepage, 1996.
117 Hildermeier, How Ideas Change Markets, 61–62.
118 Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence, 39.
119 Letter from Xavier Fels (PSA) to Luc Bastard (ACEA/Renault), 14 June 1999, DOS2008AD-10973, PSA.
120 Email from the PSA delegation about a discussion with Jim Currie, DG Environment in 1998, 23 July 2003, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
121 Email about PSA and Jim Currie discussion, 2003.
122 ACEA meeting minutes, 23 Nov. 1998, DOS2010ECR-00241, PSA.
123 Note from Lepeu to Schweitzer (Renault), 1998.
124 Internal note from PSA about monitoring, 22 Mar. 1999, DOS2008-10895, PSA.
125 Letter from Fels to ACEA, 14 June 1999, DOS2008AD-10973, PSA.
126 Note from PSA about an ACEA meeting on monitoring, 9 Apr. 1999, DOS2008AD-10973, PSA.
127 Note from Fontaine to Fels, 1999.
128 Note from Anthony Millington (ACEA Tokyo Office) to European automakers in Japan, 23 Apr. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
129 PSA comments on Millington’s note, 23 Apr. 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
130 Schnabl, “The evolution of voluntary agreements at the level of the European Union,” 95.
131 ACEA, “ACEA Commitment on CO2 emission reductions from new passenger cars in the framework of an Environmental Agreement between the European Commission and ACEA,” 29 July 1998, DOS2011ECR-00117, PSA.
132 Note from Fontaine to Fels, 1999.
133 Milor, “Non-Documents for Big Decisions.”
134 Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis,” 7.
135 Note from Fontaine to Fels, 1999.
136 Milor, “Whose Business Is Road Safety?,” 54.
137 Héritier and Eckert, “New Modes of Governance.”
138 Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis,” 8.
139 Milor, “European Technical Democracy?,” 278–279.
140 Hoffman, “Climate Change Strategy”; David Talbot and Olivier Boiral, “Le secteur de l’aluminium en quête de légitimité et d’influence: les ententes volontaires sur la réduction des émissions de gaz à effet de serre au Québec,” Entreprises et histoire 86, no. 1 (2017): 71–85.
141 Handwritten note from Luc Bastard (ACEA/Renault) to PSA, 22 Mar. 1999.
142 Milor, “Whose Business Is Road Safety?,” 51–52.
143 Näsman, “The Political Economy of Emission Standards”; Mattias Näsman and Sabine Pitteloud, “The Power and Limits of Expertise: Swiss–Swedish Linking of Vehicle Emission Standards in the 1970s and 1980s,” Business and Politics 24, no. 3 (2022): 241–260.
144 Milor, “Construire l’automobile, conduire l’Europe,” 648–649, 764.
145 Per Kågeson, “Reducing CO2 Emissions from New Cars—A Progress Report on the Car Industry’s Voluntary Agreement and an Assessment of the Need for Policy Instruments,” Jan. 2005, T&E.
146 Keay-Bright, “A Critical Analysis,” 20.
147 Bernard Jullien, Tommaso Pardi, and Sigfrido Ramírez Pérez, “The EU’s Government of the Car Industry: From “Harmonization” to Deep Incompleteness,” The EU’s Government of Industries. Markets, Institutions and Politics, eds. Bernard Jullien and Andy Smith (Abingdon, 2014): 69–95; Alice Milor, “Le lobby des PDG de l’automobile à Bruxelles, machine de guerre contre les États-Unis ? (1972–1991),” Industrie, développement et souveraineté. Ressources, valeurs et territorialités (France-Europe, XVII e–XXI e siècle), ed. Clotilde Druelle-Korn, Patrick Fridenson, Pascal Griset, and Laurent Warlouzet (Paris, 2025): 267–284.
148 Jacques Calvet’s Interview Guide for his Meeting with Stefano Micossi, Director General of DG III, 17 Apr. 1996, 12 Apr. 1996, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
149 Friedrich, Tappe, and Wurzel, “The Auto-Oil I Programme.”
150 Calvet’s Interview Guide, 12 Apr. 1996.
151 Milor, “Construire l’automobile, conduire l’Europe,” 634–659.
152 Rory Costello and Robert Thomson, “The Distribution of Power Among EU Institutions: Who Wins under Codecision and Why?,” Legislative Codecision in the European Union: Experience over Twenty Years and Implications, eds. Anne Rasmussen, Charlotte Burns, and Christine Reh (New York, 2014): 85–99.
153 Minutes of 21 Nov. 1996 meeting between four PSA representatives and Richard Wright (DG III), 25 Nov. 1996, DOS2008AD-09675, PSA.
154 Christine Meisner Rosen and Christopher C. Sellers, “The Nature of the Firm: Towards an Ecocultural History of Business,” Business History Review 75, no. 4 (Winter 1999): 577–600.
155 John Mikler, Greening the Car Industry: Varieties of Capitalism and Climate Change (Cheltenham, 2009).
156 Sluyterman, “Royal Dutch Shell.”
157 Pestre, “La mise en économie de l’environnement comme règle,” 38.
158 Patrick Moreau and Birte Wassenberg, eds., European Integration and New Anti-Europeanism (Stuttgart, 2016).
159 Sonia Mazey and Jeremy Richardson, “Institutionalizing Promiscuity: Commission-Interest Group Relations in the European Union,” The Institutionnalization of Europe, ed. Alec Stone Sweet, Wayne Sandholtz, and Neil Fligstein (Oxford, 2001).
160 Ballor, “Liberal Environmentalism”; Klebaner, Normes environnementales européennes.
161 Héritier and Eckert, “New Modes of Governance”; Paolo Bertoldi and Silvia Rezessy, “Voluntary Agreements for Energy Efficiency: Review and Results of European Experiences,” Energy & Environment 18, no. 1 (2007): 37-73.
162 Milor, “Non-documents for Big Decisions.”
163 Cornelia Woll, Le Lobbying à rebours: L’influence du politique sur la stratégie des grandes entreprises (Paris, 2011).
164 Martiel Libera, Sylvain Schirmann, and Birte Wassenberg, eds., Abstentionnisme, euroscepticisme et anti-européisme dans les élections européennes de 1979 à nos jours (Strasbourg, 2016).
165 For the time being, other recently-opened archives (Pascal Lamy and the British National Archives), which were consulted in 2023–2024, have not provided any decisive additional information.
166 Eric W. Welch, Allan Mazur, and Stuart Bretschneider, “Voluntary Behavior by Electric Utilities: Levels of Adoption and Contribution of the Climate Challenge Program to the Reduction of Carbon Dioxide,” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 19, no. 3 (2000): 407–425; Nicholas Lutsey and Daniel Sperling, “Canada’s Voluntary Agreement on Vehicle Greenhouse Gas Emissions: When the Details Matter,” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 12, no. 7 (2007): 474–487.
167 Franck Aggeri, “Environmental Policies and Innovation: A Knowledge-Based Perspective on Cooperative Approaches,” Research policy 28, no. 7 (1999): 699–617; Signe Krarup and Stephan Ramesohl, “Voluntary Agreements on Energy Efficiency in Industry—Not a Golden Key, but Another Contribution to Improve Climate Policy Mixes,” Journal of Cleaner Production 10, no. 2 (2002): 109–120; John J. Kirton and Michael J. Trebilcock, Hard Choices, Soft Law: Voluntary Standards in Global Trade, Environment and Social Governance (Aldershot/Brookfield, 2004); Antto Vihma, “Friendly Neighbor or Trojan Horse? Assessing the Interaction of Soft Law Initiatives and the UN Climate Regime,” International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics 9, no. 3 (2009): 239–262.
168 Christopher Wright and Daniel Nyberg, “An Inconvenient Truth: How Organizations Translate Climate Change into Business as Usual,” The Academy of Management Journal 60, no. 5 (2017): 1657.
169 Marco Frigessi di Rattalma, The Dieselgate: A Legal Perspective (Cham, 2017).
170 Samuel Klebaner and Sigfrido Ramírez Pérez, “The European Automotive Industry: A Strategic Sector in Search of a New Industrial Policy,” EU Industrial Policy in the Multipolar Economy, ed. Jean-Christophe Defraigne, Edoardo Traversa, Jan Wouters, and Dimitri Zurstrassen (Cheltenham, 2022): 304–331.
171 Iguchi, Divergence and Convergence.
172 Tommaso Pardi, “Prospects and Contradictions of the Electrification of the European Automotive Industry: The Role of European Union Policy,” International Journal of Automotive Technology and Management 21, no. 3 (2021): 162–179.