The development of parenting behaviors is influenced by the coparenting relationship – how parents coordinate and manage their shared parenting responsibilities. However, mothers and fathers may exhibit varying degrees of susceptibility to the coparenting relationship, and different factors may further shape their susceptibility. Longitudinal data from 182 different-sex dual-earner parent families were used (86% White, mostly middle- and upper-class families). Observations of coparenting and parenting behaviors were obtained at 3 and 9 months postpartum. Mothers and fathers reported their beliefs about parental roles and parenting at the third trimester of pregnancy and reported their parenting self-efficacy and infant temperament at 3 months. The results of cross-lagged panel models showed that the associations between coparenting and parenting were not significantly different for mothers and fathers. However, the moderators that shaped the associations between coparenting and parenting were distinct for mothers and fathers. Fathers’ less progressive parental role beliefs strengthened the association between supportive coparenting and positive parenting, and mothers’ lower parenting self-efficacy and children’s lower regulatory capacity enhanced the link between undermining coparenting and negative parenting. Implications for research and practice are discussed.