The frequency responses of circulation control and separation control using mini-spoilers for loads attenuation on plunging swept and unswept wings were compared in a water tunnel study. At the pre-stall angle-of-attack, the effectiveness of the spoilers significantly diminishes with increasing reduced frequency of the plunging motion. For the leading-edge spoiler, this happens because the roll-up of the vorticity promotes flow reattachment and reduces the effectiveness of loads attenuation. For the trailing-edge spoiler, the effectiveness of lift attenuation also decreases with increasing reduced frequency, due to the shedding of leading-edge vortices and immersion of the trailing-edge spoiler in the separated flow. The decay of the frequency response for both types of spoilers is similar, implying that it is dictated by the flow separation near the leading edge of the wing in both cases. With increasing sweep angle of the wings, the spoilers’ effectiveness decreases significantly in comparison to the unswept wing. Strong spanwise flow develops for the leading-edge spoiler, which sheds a streamwise vortex, with the same direction of rotation as the wing-tip trailing vortex. This causes partial reattachment of the flow and reduction of the separation area behind the spoiler. With increasing reduced frequency, strong leading-edge vortices dominate the flow over the wing. The leading-edge vortices generate additional vortex lift and also cause the trailing-edge spoiler to be immersed in the massively separated flows. Both factors reduce the effectiveness of the spoilers.

Lift alleviation by a mini-spoiler on aerofoils, unswept and swept wings encountering an isolated counter-clockwise vortical gust was investigated by means of force and velocity measurements. The flow separation region behind the spoiler remains little affected during the gust encounter. The maximum lift reduction is found for the static stall angle of attack. The change in the maximum lift during the gust encounter is approximately equal to that in steady freestream. The comparison with plunging aerofoils reveals that, for the same maximum gust and plunge velocity, the effectiveness of the mini-spoiler is much better in travelling gusts. This reveals the importance of the streamwise length scale of the incident gust. For the unswept wing, there is some three-dimensionality of the flow separation induced by the mini-spoiler near the wing tip. The magnitude of the lift reduction can be estimated using the aerofoil data and by making an aspect ratio correction for the reduced effective angle of attack. For the swept wing, the mini-spoiler can disrupt the formation of a leading-edge vortex induced by the incident vortex on the clean wing and can still reduce the maximum lift.