Interest in weed seed predation as an ecological weed management tactic hasled to a growing number of investigations of agronomic and environmentaleffects on predation rates. Whereas the measurements in most of thesestudies have taken place at very short timescales, from days to weeks,measurements at longer timescales (from several months to a year) havegreater relevance to the demographic impact of weed seed predation andpotential contributions from this process to ecological weed management. Ouraim was to quantify the impact of crop phase, within a corn–soybean–wheatcrop sequence, on quarterly and annual seed predation rates of giantfoxtail, giant ragweed, and velvetleaf. The study took place in areas of thenorthern U.S. Corn Belt contrasting in dominant land use: Savoy, IL(2005–2007), where corn and soybean production predominates, and EastLansing, MI (2005–2008), where crop production occurs within an oldfield/forest landscape matrix. Mean annual rates of weed seed predation bythe combined action of invertebrate and vertebrate predators were 31 ± 1.6%for giant ragweed, 37 ± 1.4% for velvetleaf, and 53 ± 1.4% for giantfoxtail. Crop phase had negligible effects upon long-term seed predationrates, accounting for less than 2% of observed variation. Weed species andsite-year, in contrast, contributed 35% and 40%, respectively, of thevariation in cumulative annual seed predation. These results are consistentwith the spatial variability in best management practices seen at spatialscales greater than the county level: weed seed predation appears to be aninherently site-specific phenomenon. New developments in managing weed seedpredation as an ecosystem service are therefore likely to have localrecommendation domains or to be driven by stochastic annual variationrelated to weather or granivore demography.