We investigated the response of experienced amyotrophic lateral sclerosis physicians to patient-based evidence pertaining to health communication. Fifteen expert amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) physicians participated in an in-person focus group. Focusing on clinical feasibility and first-hand experience, participants discussed recommendations from people with ALS and caregivers for improving communication. Data were qualitatively analyzed using conventional content analysis. Findings demonstrated shared and differing perspectives, and communication challenges. Findings suggest a difference in perspective centered on how to achieve the shared goal of patient-centered communication. We discuss asymmetry between healthcare professional perspectives and patient-based evidence, and opportunities for alignment that will advance effective health communication.